Why Simple Wills Aren’t Always Appropriate

The Background:

A widowed mother passed away in March 2025, leaving an estate valued at £600,000 after debts and funeral expenses. Her estate consisted primarily of her property and cash savings.

She had written a basic will many years earlier, without legal advice. It simply directed that her estate be divided equally among her three adult children.

The Complication:

While two of the children were financially independent, the third had severe lifelong learning disabilities and lacked the mental capacity to manage her own finances. She had always lived with the deceased and relied heavily on her for care and support.

Under the will, this child became entitled to a £200,000 inheritance. However, due to her incapacity:

  • She could not legally manage or control the funds herself.
  • The inheritance risked affecting her eligibility for essential means-tested state benefits and care support.
  • The lump sum would be legally inaccessible and unprotected without intervention.

The Legal Consequences:

To protect the vulnerable beneficiary’s interests, the family was forced to urgently apply to the Court of Protection for the appointment of a deputy to manage her financial affairs. The process:

  • Was legally necessary but time-consuming and costly.
  • Placed a significant emotional burden on the family during an already distressing period.
  • Could have been entirely avoided with appropriate estate planning.

What Should Have Happened:

Had the deceased taken professional advice, her will could have included a discretionary or vulnerable beneficiary trust. This would have:

  • Ensured the inheritance was properly managed for the benefit of the vulnerable child.
  • Protected access to means-tested benefits and services.
  • Avoided the need for Court of Protection involvement.
  • Provided clarity and peace of mind for the whole family.

Key Takeaway

Not all families are the same, and neither should all wills be. A “simple” will may seem sufficient, but in cases involving vulnerable beneficiaries, it can create significant unintended consequences. Professional legal advice ensures that your wishes are honoured and your loved ones are protected legally and practically.

At Hedges Law, we make the process of writing your will simple, compassionate, and tailored to protect what matters most.

Read More